| Period | Name of Brother | Lodge | Rank | Remarks |
| 1780 – 1788 | Bro. Archibald Edgar | St. Andrew No. 102 | Provincial Grand Master | |
| 1788 | Bro. Rev. Middleton Howard | St. Andrew No. 102 | Provincial Grand Master | |
| 1788 – 1843 | Interregnum | |||
| 1843 – 1848 | Bro. Rev. William Godfrey Pollard Burton | Affiliate – Lodge Elgin No. 415 S.C
Sussex Lodge E.C. |
Provincial Grand Master | |
| 1848 – 1854 | Bro. Dr. James McFayden | Affiliate – Lodge Glenlyon No. 346 S.C.
Sussex Lodge E.C. |
Provincial Grand Master | |
| 1854 – 1863 | Bro. Colin Campbell | |||
| 1863 – 1871 | Bro. James Kay Fingzies | |||
| 1871 – 1901 | Bro. Samuel Constantine Burke | Elected but not appointed | ||
| 1901 – 1904 | Bro. Dr. James Ogilvie | Provincial Grand Master | ||
| 1904 – 1911 | Bro. Dr. James Ogilvie | District Grand Master | Changed from Province to District | |
| 1911 – 1915 | Bro. The Hon. Edmund Archibald H. Haggart | District Grand Master | ||
| 1915 – 1923 | Bro. Adam Roxborough | District Grand Master | ||
| 1923 – 1924 | Bro. John Hartley Duff | District Grand Master | ||
| 1924 – 1927 | Bro. Stephen James Streadwick | District Grand Master | ||
| 1927 – 1942 | Bro. Robert Gillies | District Grand Master | ||
| 1942 – 1957 | Bro. John James Mills | The Glenyon Lodge S.C. 346 | District Grand Master | |
| 1957 – 1964 | Bro. Alfred Agustus Grant | Lodge Imperial Service No. 978 S.C. | District Grand Master | |
| 1964 – 1969 | Bro. Jackson McLaren Wint | The Glenyon Lodge 346 S.C. | District Grand Master | |
| 1969 – 1974 | Bro. Carcel Gilward Grant | Lodge Clarendon Kilwinning No. 1427 S.C. | District Grand Master | |
| 1974 – 1979 | Bro. Lloyd Gilbert Wong | Lodge Imperial Service, No. 978 | District Grand Master | |
| 1979 – 1984 | Bro. Oswald Leo McDonald | Liguanea Lodge No. 1479 S.C. | District Grand Master | |
| 1984 – 1989 | Bro. Rudyard Owen Cutherbert White | The Glenyon Lodge S.C. 346 | District Grand Master | |
| 1990 – 1995 | Bro. Prof. The Hon. Hugh Hastings Wynter | Semper Fidelis No. 1530 N.D | District Grand Master | |
| 1996 – 2001 | Bro. Dr. Barryington Earl Anthony Miller | Lodge Clarendon 1427 S.C. | District Grand Master | |
| 2001 – 2007 | Bro. Frank Constantine Mitchell | Lodge Imperial Service | District Grand Master | |
| 2007 – 2012 | Bro. Lloyd Rudolph Moore | St. John 623 S.C. | District Grand Master | |
| 2012 – 2017 | Bro. Col. Lemuel Agustus Lindo | Mico 1583 S.C. | District Grand Master | |
| 2017-Current | Bro. Errol Charles Alberga Jnr. | Liguanea Lodge No. 1479 S.C. | District Grand Master | |
From 1780 to Current
Complied from History of the District Grand Lodge of Jamaica by Br. John Sinclair – Lodge Wolmers
By Bro.Kevin Francis – Lodge Imperial Service
